Genetically Engineered (GE) Foods Labeling (Prop 37 CA)
I thought I’d share some of my thoughts and knowledge on the
new initiative to label genetically engineered food. I’m not going to tell you
what to vote for because even I’m still trying to decide. I’m also not claiming
to be some kind of expert. I am just a normal person like most people trying to
figure out what I should vote for. I can’t exactly say that I have an unbiased
opinion either because I already practice staying away from genetically engineered
food. I trust Mother Nature and believe that God made everything perfect. I
don’t really think that there is a need to change the DNA of our food.
Read More
First of all, what are genetically engineered (GE) foods
(also known as GMO – genetically modified organisms)? It means that the genetic
material (DNA) of a living organism has been changed. Most of the time plants
are changed to be able to resist pests and pesticides. Sometimes living
organisms are genetically modified to grow faster and bigger. Most genetically
engineered crops are corn and soybeans, but other common crops are alfalfa,
canola, cotton, papaya, sugar beets, and zucchini.
What is Prop 37 proposing?
Just to quickly summarize it, here are the 3 main proposals:
1)
Requires that most GE foods sold be labeled as such. All plants, whether
partially or entirely GE have to be labeled.
2)
Requires the Department of Public Health to
regulate the labeling
3)
Allows individuals to sue food manufactures who
violate the labeling provisions
This is where it gets confusing. There will be some food
products that will be exempt from this labeling. That includes alcoholic
beverages, organic foods, and restaurant food. Also animal products such as
beef or chicken that were not directly produced through genetic engineering
even if the animal was fed with GE crops.
Alcohol:
What plants are used in alcohol? grapes (wine), barley,
wheat, corn (beer, spirits), potatoes, and fruit.
I would guess that if you’re drinking beer that it contains
GE plants in it because it’s mostly made with wheat and corn. Both of those
crops are usually GE. When drinking wine it’d be easier to avoid GE food
because I’m not aware of grapes being GE. If you get organic wine then you’re
even guaranteed they didn’t use GMO or pesticides.
Why wouldn’t alcohol be included?
I’m guessing that maybe people feel that if you’re drinking
alcohol maybe you wouldn’t be as health conscious or maybe we’d just not care
as much because it’s not something we drink every day. Or perhaps alcohol isn’t
regulated in the same manner as food. What’s your guess? I’m not too sure on
this one, but it won’t really affect me since I’m not a big drinker.
Organic foods are
excluded.
This one is easy. Certified Organic food cannot
intentionally contain GE ingredients, so why waste the time and effort to
regulate this when it’s already regulated by the USDA.
Restaurant Food:
I’m going to guess that restaurant food is excluded because
it would be difficult to regulate. I actually always assume the worst when I go
to a restaurant because I would guess that most (especially fast food)
restaurants would want to buy the cheapest food for their restaurant and most
of the time it will be low quality unless you’re going to an upscale or
health-type restaurant. This doesn’t bother me at all because I try not to eat
out and keep it to once a week at the most.
Animal products
such as beef or chicken that were not directly produced through genetic
engineering even if the animal was fed with GE crops are excluded.
This is yet another confusing one. Why would animal products
be excluded such as beef and chicken?
“Not directly produced through genetic engineering” - This
tells me that if the animal was genetically engineered it would need to be
labeled. But if the animal was fed with GE crops then it doesn’t need to be
labeled. Most factory farmed animals are fed with GE crops such as corn (not
part of their natural diet by the way). I’m not aware of any animal that is
genetically engineered. I know that there was a proposal to introduce a GE salmon
that grows faster and bigger, but it hasn’t been approved. From what I read
in the proposal for Prop 37, I would believe that this salmon would have to be
labeled if it was introduced to the market. You can avoid eating animals that
were fed with GE crops by purchasing organic meats and looking for beef that is
pasture raised and also grass-fed. Chickens should be cage-free. Another option
would be to go vegan and not eat animal products at all.
If this proposition passes, I think people are going to be
very surprised that a lot of their processed food contains GE ingredients. It
seems like most processed food contains some type of “corn” product such as
High Fructose Corn Syrup. It makes me wonder if people saw the label GE all
over their food, that people would start to question the health of their food
or where it came from. Is it possible that processed or GE food would become
more expensive and piss off a bunch of people? Possible but not for certain. Let’s
just say it’s possible - If you shop at non-health food stores
where that label might be plastered everywhere and prices might go up as
companies try to continue to make as much profit as possible and also possibly try
to bully us into turning away from this labeling system. I think that could
piss off lots of people. On the plus side, it’s possible that the demand for
organic food would increase, which would cause organic food prices to decrease.
Let’s all consider this though, when we asked companies to add information to
their products such as nutrition info and ingredient lists, did the prices go
up? Not that I noticed, so it’s possible that the prices won’t be affected as
well. There are a lot of “ifs” here.
Whether this proposal passed or not, people that care most
about staying away from GE food are more likely to do their own homework and
find a way to stay away from GE foods like myself. I find it fairly easy to not
eat GE food. For example, buying organic food, shopping at health food stores
and farmers markets, frequently cook at home instead of eating at restaurants,
and staying away from processed food as much as possible.
Find tips on how to stay away from GE (GMO) food here: http://nongmoshoppingguide.com/tips-for-avoiding-gmos.html
I do love the idea of pushing out companies like Monsanto,
Dupont and DOW and putting pressure on everyone to find new options because our
system now in my opinion is not sustainable. If you have interest in finding
out more about GE or GMO watch the film The Future of Food or Food Inc or watch
both. They’re both available on Netflix.
I also find it scary that large companies like Monsanto,
Dupont and DOW don’t want people to know what’s in their food. If GE food is so
safe, what does it matter if people know more about it? These large companies
are also the supporters of opposing this proposition. Tip: Look up the
background information of these companies. “Monsanto
was also one of the most important producers of Agent Orange for United States
Military operations in Vietnam”
On my facebook page I had mentioned that I saw a commercial
that opposed Prop 37 that was very misleading. From my memory, and maybe you’ve
seen it, the commercial showed that this proposition would require that dog
food be labeled but not beef or chicken that’s for human consumption. In the
commerical it states that the measure
“makes no sense at all” because it mandates that some foods be labeled while
others are exempted by the proposed law. It also says, “It just gives an
indication of the arbitrary and completely illogical nature of this ill
conceived proposition”. If you read the proposition proposal, you can easily
see the reason for this. It’s because dog food contains animal products AND grain/corn products that are more than
likely from GE crops. Since dog food has GE products in it, then it will be
labeled. However, beef and chicken are exempt because the animal themselves are
not GE. See how the commercial is misleading and not totally true?
Do you believe you have the right to know if your food has
been modified from its natural state?
Resources and helpful
links:
The complete official
voter guide where you can find all of the proposition details: http://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2012/general/pdf/complete-vig-v2.pdf
Supporters of
opposing Prop 37 are using scare tactics: http://napavalleyregister.com/news/opinion/mailbag/prop-opposition-resorting-to-scare-tactics/article_1b570072-11cb-11e2-84cd-0019bb2963f4.html
See who is supporting
No on Prop 37: Coalition Against the Deceptive Food Labeling Scheme,
sponsored by Farmers, Food Producers, and Grocers. Major funding by Monsanto
Company, E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co., Grocery Manufacturers Association
(GMA) and more than 40 food company
members. For a full list of donors visit www.NoProp37.com/donors
No on Prop 37
supporters: http://www.noprop37.com/facts/
Yes on Prop 37
supporters: http://www.carighttoknow.org/
See who is supporting Yes on Prop 37. Endorsers include:
the California Nurses Association, California Democratic Party, California Labor
Federation, United Farm Workers, American Public Health Association, Consumers
Union, Sierra Club, Whole Foods Market, California Council of Churches, Organic
Consumers Association, Center for Food Safety, Consumer Federation of America,
Mercola Health Resources, Public Citizen, and Food Democracy Now! http://www.carighttoknow.org/endorsements
How to avoid GMO
foods: http://nongmoshoppingguide.com/tips-for-avoiding-gmos.html
What is GE/GMO? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_organism

